Starbucks just closed ~250 cafes — while its comparable sales are running the strongest in years. Both are true. Here's why.

For the first time in 27 years, Starbucks China posted a net decline in store count in a single quarter — and yet management insists the company is "in recovery." Both can be true, and the reason reveals a bigger corporate reinvention than the closure headlines suggest: Starbucks is pruning ~250 underperforming North American cafes even as comparable sales run the strongest in years, and the market treats the cuts as portfolio hygiene, not distress, though shares are down 11.45% over the prior month.

Behind the scenes, the company is weighing a ~$3B majority-stake sale of its Japan unit, extending an asset-light Asia pivot that already saw a 60% China stake sold to Boyu Capital — a strategic shift, not a temporary restructuring. With Chinese rivals led by Luckin (36,310 stores) repricing the entire coffee market downward, the old owned-store model no longer pencils out, so Starbucks is choosing capital discipline over ownership.

The Closures Are a Real-Estate Correction, Not a Demand Problem

Starbucks is closing ~250 underperforming North American cafes, a low single-digit share of its 18,371-store regional base.

The market barely reacted. This is the second closure round under CEO Brian Niccol, following the 627-store cut in the prior fiscal year's Q4. The restructuring charge of $302.6 million in the most recent quarter and $892 million in full-year FY2025 is front-loaded.

The bull case is that transaction growth is accelerating, margin expansion is real, and guidance was raised. The company closes underperforming stores rather than defending them.

The Japan Sale Is the Same Story From a Different Continent

Starbucks is weighing a majority-stake sale of its Japan unit valued at ~$3B. This is part of the "Back to Starbucks" strategy and overseas asset sales.

The company sold 60% of its China unit to Hong Kong-based Boyu Capital and exited its entire 50% Korea stake in 2021. This is the asset-light / royalty-model pivot. North America operating margin fell to 13.6% from 21% a year earlier.

Why China Broke the Owned-Store Math

Luckin has opened 36,310 stores globally, adding over 2,700 net new locations within three months. Luckin cups run for a fraction of the RMB30 ($4.20) traditional premium price, around RMB10 per cup.

Cotti, Manner, and Mixue Group add pressure. Starbucks China Q2 FY2026 same-store sales rose just 0.5%, average transaction value fell 1.6%, and store count posted its first single-quarter net decline (net decrease of 20) in 27 years. Coffee split into cheap-daily vs premium-experience segments.

The low-margin owned-store model can't win the price war.

The Real Story Is the Shift in Strategic Priorities

The two Starbucks headlines everyone is treating separately — North American store closures and the Japan stake sale — are the same story: Starbucks is quietly converting from a global store operator into a North American margin machine plus an offshore royalty collector. The Chinese coffee price war is the reason the old owned-store model no longer pencils out.

Recovery in One Region, Retreat in Another

The China narrative diverges by source: North American closures read as healthy "portfolio hygiene" with transactions accelerating, while Starbucks China logged its first net store decline in 27 years with flat same-store sales (+0.5%) and a falling ticket (-1.6%) — recovery in one region, retreat in another. The 250 closures represent roughly 1% of the North American footprint measured against the ~18,000-store base, not the far larger share some early reads implied. The true cash cost is less than the restructuring charge.

Starbucks is trading global ownership for North American margin plus offshore royalties.

*Juan Valdez is a licensed brand. The Juan Valdez parties are not sponsors of this offering. This is a paid advertisement for Green Coffee Company’s Regulation A offering. Please read the offering circular at https://invest.greencoffeecompany.com/. Timelines are subject to change. Listing on the NASDAQ is contingent upon necessary approvals, and reserving a ticker symbol does not guarantee a company’s public listing.